44 Years Later, This Ambitious 2-Part Fantasy Series Returned Before a Quick Cancellation

Fantasy Island is a classic fantasy drama that ran on ABC from 1977 to 1984. Ricardo Montalbán was the hunky, dashing, and enigmatic Mr. Roarke who occupied a mysterious island that could grant its guests incredible wishes. What lives on in most people’s memories is his sidekick, Tattoo (Hervé Villechaize), who would announce new guest arrivals by shouting, “De plane! De plane!” at the beginning of every episode.

The series was emblematic of the time period in a lot of ways — original, fun, and, in several ways, very problematic. But that hasn’t stopped the entertainment world from bringing Fantasy Island back to life several times (including a one-season revival series in 1998 and a horror film adaptation in 2020). But a sequel series a few years back really captured the magic of Fantasy Island in a memorable way.

What Is 2021’s ‘Fantasy Island’ About?

In 2021, Fox aired the first season of a brand-new version of Fantasy Island. This time the adaptation is actually a sequel to the 1970s series, picking up several decades after the original. Elena Roarke (Roselyn Sánchez) is the grand-niece of Mr. Roarke, and she has taken up the mantle of running the mystical island to keep the magic within her family. She continues to offer guests the chance to stay on the island and fulfill one of their greatest dreams.

The island doesn’t always grant these wishes in the most straight-forward way, but each guest does learn a valuable lesson, so that they still always take what they need from the island before returning home. There is magic all around, and romance is in the air, especially with Javier (John Gabriel Rodriquez) as Elena’s love interest. Instead of a man as her sidekick though, Elena has Ruby Akuda (Kiara Barnes). In the premiere episode, Ruby travels to the island to gain more time before succumbing to a fatal illness. She ends up turning into her younger self, and then decides to stay on the island to assist Elena. Their partnership is a compelling, feminist twist on the original show’s island staff.

‘Fantasy Island’ Is a Fun Continuation of the Original Series

Fantasy Island might be a sequel to the original, but it’s not necessary for you to have seen the 1970s show in order to watch the new adaptation. In fact, each episode contains a fresh storyline where you can see the island’s magic at work, but it still includes the original’s entertaining fantasy aspects. One guest gets to spend her stay on the island eating as much as she wants because her job requires her to stay thin. In another, a woman gets to see versions of her life if she chooses her boyfriend or an arranged marriage her parents want her to carry out. A stand-out episode, “Once Upon a Time in Havana,” portrays a young teen who is transported to Cuba in the 1960s so that she can learn the origins of her family’s story. This time travel allows the girl to be more accepting of her relatives and helps her move forward in a healthier way on her own path.

Each island wish is fulfilled in a dreamy, yet still realistic way. There are also storylines that carry over through the season, as we learn more about Elena’s own relationship to her family and to the island itself. The sequel works because of the leading performance by Sánchez. She’s the grounded, calm conduit who helps facilitate all of the guests’ wishes, but she’s also trying to find fulfillment in her own life. Her scenes with Barnes are also intriguing, as they establish a friendship that is both nurturing and somewhat complicated. But the real reason that Fantasy Island is so fun to watch is all of the guest stars that pop up on the island. Season 1 features Scandal‘s Bellamy Young, real-life married couple Odette and Dave Annable, and the reunion of the fabulous trio of Melrose Place ladies, Daphne Zuniga, Josie Bissett, and Laura Leighton.

There’s also an episode centered around the late comedy legend, Leslie Jordan. But Season 2 didn’t hold back when it comes to television legends either, with episodes starring Desperate Housewives‘ Teri Hatcher and 90210‘s Jason Priestley. Seeing who is going to appear in every new episode makes the fantasy series even more entertaining and exciting to watch. In the end, it seems that not enough people were willing to travel to Fantasy Island. The series was cancelled in 2023 after just two seasons. Although it only consists of 23 episodes, the fantasy drama is still worthy of a binge-watch, even if you aren’t familiar with the original series. If nothing else, watching the series is a nice tropical escape from the real world.